Democracy’s two faces

View as pdf»Visa som PDF

 

Purpose

  • Examine the group’s attitudes to democracy

  • Give the participants a chance of airing mixed feelings in two Four corners discussions

1. Four corners: positive aspects of democracy

What do you see as the positive side of democracy?

1. Everyone can participate
2. The rulers are supported by a majority
3. Decisions are better
4. Something else

(Someone may ask for definitions and explanations; they should be told that the participants are free to interpret the alternatives as they see fit.

Those who choose “Something else” tend to have negative reasons – none of the other corners suits them. On closer thought, perhaps they will think of a positive aspect.)

2. Four corners: negative aspects of democracy

What makes democracy difficult or a problem? For example, what might be the negative consequences of an attempt to make your own group (workplace, association, municipality, country) democratic?

1. Chaos
2. No one would take responsibility
3. Poorer decisions
4. Something else

3. Summary

Draw the participants’ attention to which corners attracted the most and the fewest of them in each of the two exercises.

Comments

In examining the positive aspects of democracy the ‘Everyone can participate’ corner usually attracts the largest number and ‘The rulers are supported by a majority’ corner a much smaller number.

This exercise can be used to advantage as the introduction to longer, more systematic work on democracy issues. If relatively few of the participants adhere to the alternative ‘The rulers are supported by a majority’ (the core of a conventional Western perception of democracy), this should be a subject for further reflection later on.

 

Share:Email this to someoneShare on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInPrint this page
Posted in ABC of Democracy, Applications